Updated November 2026
As a default, give a candidate a few working days to a week to accept a job offer, and agree the deadline with them on the offer call instead of springing it in the letter. Set the date around their real decision, meaning other processes, a partner's view and their notice period. Give longer for senior, relocating or equity-heavy offers, and only go shorter when there is a real reason you can say out loud.
A 24 or 48 hour deadline feels like control. In practice it leaves a candidate with other processes two bad options, to say no or to say yes while still interviewing. The second is worse for you, because that person is the one who walks away during their notice period, as in our guide to a candidate backing out after accepting.
Large employers get away with tight deadlines because their brand does part of the selling. A Series A startup is asking for trust from someone it met a month ago, and pressure reads as insecurity. Use the deadline to plan your side, such as when to call the runner-up.
An illustrative example runs through this page. Jonah is CEO of a 35-person Series A startup selling inventory software to restaurant groups. He wants to hire Aiko, a senior product designer with a final round at a large tech company next week and a written offer from another startup.
On the offer call, walk through the package, then ask what the candidate needs to decide and by when. Say the date back and agree it before you hang up, so the letter only confirms it.
Three things set the real date, and founders usually only think of the first.
Equity-heavy offers need longer because candidates often want an accountant or a friend at another startup to read the option terms. A clear equity explanation on the call shortens this more than a firmer deadline does, and our guide to making job offers that get accepted covers the call itself.
A tighter date is reasonable when you have a strong second finalist who is about to take another job, or when a team plan depends on a start date you cannot move. If you would not say the reason to the candidate in plain words, it is pressure.
Never invent a rival candidate. A made-up deadline that quietly moves when the date passes tells the candidate how you will treat them later.
Jonah had no second finalist ready, so a short deadline had no honest reason behind it. Aiko asked for eight working days to finish her final round, and he agreed, asking her to call him first if anything in his offer became the deciding factor.
What happens after the offer call usually falls into one of three patterns.
| What happens | What it usually means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| They ask for more time | Another process or a family conversation is running late. | Agree once, ask what will be settled by the new date, and set a call for that day. |
| They go quiet | They are leaning elsewhere and find it awkward to say. | Phone, do not email. Ask what has changed and whether anything in your offer is the problem. |
| They use your offer to bargain elsewhere | Your number is being shown to another employer or their current one. | Ask directly where they stand. Decide your ceiling in advance and do not bid against an offer you have not heard about. |
A first request for more time is often a good sign, because candidates who have decided against you usually just say no. The last days of a contested close are covered in our guide to closing a candidate with multiple offers.
While the offer is open, tell your second choice that you have made an offer to another candidate, that they were close, and that you will update them by a named date. Then send that update on time.
Do not say you are "still deciding" when you are not. If their own deadline elsewhere lands first, tell them where you stand and let them choose. Aiko accepted on day six, and the runner-up, Nils, heard from Jonah personally that afternoon and asked to stay in touch.
We are a fixed-fee recruiting partner for funded startups across North America, Europe and APAC, and have helped 500+ startups from Seed to Series D. One dedicated recruiter runs each search end to end, including support through offer, so someone is tracking the candidate's other processes and timing while your deadline runs.
The fee is fixed and agreed upfront, averaging 6 to 9% of salary. For an illustrative senior product designer on $130,000, it is $11,500, with part paid as an advance at the start of the search and the balance when the candidate accepts. The details are on our pricing page.
Rarely. It suits a candidate with no other processes and no one to consult, which is uncommon for experienced hires. A few working days to a week, agreed on the offer call, is a better default.
Yes, once you have agreed it on the call. The letter should confirm the date the candidate already heard, so it never reads as a surprise or an ultimatum. Our offer letter template has a line for it.
Call them before deciding anything. If they have a clear reason and a firm new date, a short extension is usually worth it. If they cannot give you either, tell them the offer will lapse on a specific date and move to your runner-up. Whether an offer can be withdrawn, and what it means once accepted, depends on the country and state, so check with an employment lawyer if it comes to that.
Worth a brief chat about your next hire? Book a free call.