Running a probation review at a startup: confirm, extend or end

running-a-probation-review-at-a-startup:-confirm,-extend-or-end

Updated November 2026

To run a probation review at a startup, set three to five probation goals from the role's scorecard on the first day, hold a written check at the midpoint, and finish with a decision meeting that has three possible outcomes: confirm, extend with specific goals, or end. Decide on evidence collected against those goals, and confirm the outcome in writing the same day.

Most startups skip this. The end date passes in a busy month and the person is confirmed by default, so any problem surfaces months later, when the conversation is harder.

Rules on probation, notice and dismissal differ by country and by contract, including whether an extension is possible at all. Check local rules and your own employment contracts before you set dates or act on a review.

Day one: turn the scorecard into probation goals

Take the job scorecard you hired against and turn each outcome into something visible by the end of probation. Send them in writing in the first week, as part of onboarding, and ask the new hire to flag anything unrealistic.

Our illustrative example is a 30-person Series A payments startup reviewing two hires from the same month: Kofi, an account executive, and Mei, a backend engineer.

Scorecard outcomeProbation goalEvidence at review
Kofi, AE: builds qualified pipelinePipeline at an agreed level by the end of probation (illustrative target)CRM pipeline report
Kofi, AE: keeps deals forecastableEvery open deal has next step, close date and call notes in the CRMSpot check of ten deals
Mei, engineer: ships in the payments areaOwns and ships one feature end to endThe feature in production, review history
Mei, engineer: works well with the teamGives useful code reviews and joins the on-call rotaTwo peer conversations

Notice Kofi's goal about CRM notes. Founders leave process goals out because they feel petty next to a revenue number, then cannot fairly raise them at the review. If it matters in month three, it belongs on the list in week one.

Midpoint: a written check, not a chat

The midpoint check is where most of the value sits, because it means the final meeting holds no surprises.

Day 1
Goals agreed
Three to five goals from the scorecard, sent in writing
Midpoint
Written check
On track, at risk or off track, per goal
Two weeks before the end
Evidence pulled
Work samples, numbers, peer input, your notes
Final week
Decision meeting
Confirm, extend with goals, or end

Mark each goal on track, at risk or off track, add one line of evidence, and send it after a 30-minute conversation. A midpoint note that says "all good" when a goal is at risk does more harm than no note, because it is what the new hire will remember.

At the payments startup, Mei was on track everywhere. Kofi was on track for pipeline and at risk on CRM notes, and his manager wrote exactly that, with two examples of deals that had no next step.

Evidence, not impressions

Two weeks before the end, gather what you will decide on. Left to the night before, it becomes a feeling and two anecdotes.

  • The work itself: shipped features, deals, campaigns or tickets, looked at directly rather than described.
  • Numbers the role produces: pipeline, response times, cycle time, with the target written next to them.
  • Two or three peers: ask what they would miss if this person left, and what they work around.
  • Your own dated notes: a line a week is enough, and it stops the last fortnight outweighing the first two months.
Red flag: a review where the strongest evidence is "the team likes him" or "she seems sharp". Likeability and confidence are real, but they are not on the scorecard, and they are exactly what made the interview go well. If you cannot point to a piece of work, you are reviewing the interview again.

Check the other direction too. If the role changed during probation, or the promised access and onboarding never arrived, write that down, because some misses belong to you.

The decision meeting, outcome by outcome

Book a dedicated meeting in the final week, separate from any one-to-one. Say the outcome in the first minute, walk through the evidence against each goal, then send a written summary that afternoon.

Confirm

Even a clear yes deserves a real meeting. A specific confirmation with a next challenge tells Mei you were paying attention.

Sample wording: confirm
Mei, I want to confirm your role today, and not as a formality. You shipped the settlement export end to end, and two engineers told me your reviews made their code better. Next quarter I'd like you to own the reconciliation work. I'll send this in writing this afternoon.

Extend with specific goals

An extension works when one or two goals are close and the person has shown they respond to feedback. Give it a fixed length, no more than two goals and a weekly check. Kofi fits this. The hard part of the job is working, and the gap is a habit.

Sample wording: extend
Kofi, your pipeline is where we hoped, and that matters. The CRM side isn't: in the ten deals I checked, six had no call notes or next step, so we can't forecast them. I'm extending your probation by six weeks with one goal, every open deal fully updated each Friday. We'll check it together every week, and I'll confirm in writing today.

Avoid extending simply to postpone a decision you have already made. If you would not confirm the person even after hitting the new goals, end probation now.

End

If the midpoint said off track and nothing moved, the meeting should hold no surprises. Keep it short and kind. If the problem looks more like a mismatch that only showed up later, our guide to a bad hire covers that situation.

Sample wording: end
I've decided to end your employment at the end of probation. We set four goals on your first day, and at the midpoint and today we've talked about where they fell short, especially the two delivery goals. I know this is hard to hear. Let's go through the practical details, and how you'd like the team to be told.

Where Funded.club fits

We are a fixed-fee recruiting partner for funded startups across North America, Europe and APAC, with fees from $4,900 to $21,900 per hire agreed upfront (see pricing). One dedicated recruiter runs each search end to end, with first screened candidates within 7 days and 33 days on average from kick-off to hire.

Frequently asked questions

What should a probation review include?

It should cover each goal agreed on the first day, the evidence against it, and one of three outcomes: confirm, extend with specific goals, or end, followed by a written summary the same day.

Should you extend probation or end it?

Extend when one or two goals are close and the person has acted on feedback since the midpoint. End when goals were clear, the midpoint flagged them and nothing changed.

What if a startup forgot to hold a probation review?

Hold the conversation anyway, using the same goals and evidence, and treat it as a normal performance check. Then put the day-one goals and midpoint check into onboarding for every future hire.

Worth a brief chat about your next hire? Book a free call.

Hiring after a funding round?

First candidates in 7 days. Fixed-fee, no commission.

See pricing Book a free call Try the Growth Planner