Updated November 2026
Yes, ask candidates for their salary expectations, but share your range first and ask on the first call rather than at offer stage. Ask what they expect from this role, never what they earn now or earned before. The expectation is the number you need, and in several US states and cities asking about pay history is restricted.
Our illustrative example is a 30-person Series A startup hiring a senior product designer. Maya, the co-founder and CEO, runs the first 30-minute screen herself. The company's band for the level is $140,000 to $165,000 base plus stock options, set using the approach in our guide to startup salary bands. These are illustrative figures, so benchmark against current data for your market.
Share your range first, then ask
Founders often hold the range back, hoping the candidate names a lower number first. It rarely works with senior people, who will either refuse to answer or name a high figure to protect themselves. Saying the range first sets a fair frame and tells the candidate you are not playing games.
The question is about expectations for this job. Questions about current salary anchor the offer to whatever the candidate's last employer chose to pay, which can carry forward old gaps. Rules on salary history questions and on publishing ranges differ by country and state, so check local rules for every place you hire, and if a range is in the job ad, make sure the one you say out loud matches it.
"What did you earn in your last role?"
"What is your absolute minimum?"
"Is that figure base salary or total pay?"
"How do you weigh equity against cash?"
The "absolute minimum" question deserves its own warning. A candidate who gives you their floor and then receives exactly that will remember it, often around the time a recruiter calls with something better.
Why the first call and not the offer
A pay mismatch found at offer stage costs everyone four weeks of interviews. Found in the first ten minutes, it costs one call. The same goes for the candidate, who is usually running other processes and would rather know early.
Ask once, early, and write the exact answer into your applicant tracking notes. Before the offer, check back with a short question such as "has anything changed on pay since we first spoke?" Candidates who picked up a competing offer mid-process will usually tell you, and you avoid an offer built on a number that is a month out of date.
Make sure only one person asks. If a recruiter, the hiring manager and the founder each raise pay separately, the candidate starts to feel worked on, and three different notes on file will not agree.
What to do with the three answers
Almost every reply falls into one of three groups. Each needs a different next step, and none needs a negotiation on the first call.
| Answer | What it usually means | Your next step |
|---|---|---|
| Inside the range | The frame worked. The figure they name tells you roughly where in the band they see themselves. | Note the figure and move on. If they name a number below your range, plan to pay inside the band anyway. |
| Above the range | Either a total pay figure, a different level in mind, or a real gap. | Ask whether it is base or total, then check their experience against the next level's written expectations. |
| Will not name a number | Often caution after being low-balled before, sometimes a tactic. | Restate your range and ask if anything in it rules the role out. Do not press. |
The below-range case is the one founders get wrong. Paying someone under the band because they asked for less saves a little cash and creates a person who will find out, usually from a colleague, and start looking.
In our example, the designer Maya screened said $175,000. Maya's follow-up question showed the figure included a bonus at the designer's current company, and the expected base was $160,000, inside the band. Had the gap been real, the honest move was to say so, ask whether her portfolio showed the next level up, and part ways kindly if it did not.
Base, total package and equity without numbers
Many candidates think in total pay because their current employer pays a bonus or stock. Always confirm which one you are hearing, and describe your own offer in the same terms, so you compare like with like.
Equity is harder to discuss on a first call, and you should not quote grant sizes before you know the level. You can still describe how it works at your company, which tells the candidate whether it matters to them.
The answer shapes the offer later. A candidate who wants more cash and cares little about equity will compare your offer differently from one who wants a stake. For sizing the grant itself, see how many stock options to offer, and for the offer call, our guide to job offers that get accepted.
Where Funded.club fits
We are a fixed-fee recruiting partner for funded startups across North America, Europe and APAC, and have helped 500+ startups from Seed to Series D. One dedicated recruiter runs each search end to end. Give us your range at kick-off and every candidate hears it on the first screening call, so nobody on your shortlist is surprised at offer stage. First screened candidates arrive within 7 days.
Our fee is agreed upfront and averages 6 to 9% of salary, against the 20 to 25% typical of contingency recruiters. See pricing for the bands.
Frequently asked questions
Is it legal to ask a candidate about their salary expectations?
Asking what a candidate expects for the role is generally accepted. Asking about current or past pay is restricted in several US states and cities, and rules on pay ranges differ by country and state, so check local rules where you hire.
Should the employer or the candidate name a number first?
The employer should. Sharing your range first saves time, builds trust and stops senior candidates from inflating their figure to protect themselves.
What if a candidate asks for more than the top of the range?
Check whether their figure is base or total pay, then whether their experience matches the next level up. If neither closes the gap, say so plainly and let them decide whether to continue.
Worth a brief chat about your next hire? Book a free call.
Hiring after a funding round?
First candidates in 7 days. Fixed-fee, no commission.